Like most gardeners, I've become used to the names of plants. Botanists have revised the names of a great number of plants recently for scientific reasons. As mentioned in my last post, the American asters have all been removed from the genus Aster.
I have had a difficult time wrapping my mind around the new names, such as Symphyotrichum novae-angliae, or Hylotelephium. But should the new names be resisted simply because they are unfamiliar? Historically, plant names have changed, and gardeners have adapted. If I walked into a garden center today and asked for Funkia or Megasea, I'd get some funny looks. One hundred years ago these were the names Gertrude Jekyll used in her book Colour Schemes For the Flower Garden, for Hosta and Bergenia, respectively. (See Colour Schemes For the Flower Garden, p. 208 (1986 ed.) (1st published 1908).)
Gardeners of the world, unite and take over! (No, wait, I got a bit carried away there.) Gardeners, embrace the new names in the knowledge that in a hundred years, no one will remember the name Cimicifuga. In the meantime, I intend to use both. This is Cimicifuga/Actaea 'Black Negligee.'
6 comments:
Botanical names definitely have their place, and for some unknown reason I tend to remember them better than the common names. But I HATE it when botanists decide to change the official names. It muddles my teeny, tiny peanut-sized brain. ;-)
It's like trying to remember a friend's new last name after she gets married. I just hope the botanists give me enough time to get used to these names before they change them again. And what's the deal with the name "Chrysanthemum"?
Hello Mr McGregors's Daughter,
I wish the taxonomists could have let the genus Aster alone - it's a lot harder to make anything rhyme with Symphyotrichum.
Funkia - I have known a few people who used that one!
Annie at the Transplantable Rose
Annie - Aster, disaster, atomic blaster. Symphyotrichum, psych 'em, like 'em. Yeah, definitely not the same.
Heh... I'm chuckling, because I do the same re: listing both actaea and cimicifuga. Partly because the former is so much more fun to say, but partly (I admit) because I don't want anyone to think that I don't know it is changing. lol. Stupid pride.
Kim - if you think that's funny, you should hear my say the Latin names:"HOY-ker-a, HUE-ker-a, whatever, Coralbells-thingies."
Post a Comment